ChurnLeak vs Stripe Smart Retries
By the ChurnLeak team · Updated
The short answer
Stripe Smart Retries and ChurnLeak work together rather than replacing each other. Smart Retries recharge a failed card at good times, which fixes failures like insufficient funds. ChurnLeak shows everything still unpaid after that as one dollar total, also finds subscriptions with no valid card and customers on retired prices, and emails customers in your own product's name to update their card. Keep Smart Retries on and add ChurnLeak for what retries cannot fix.
Side by side
| Stripe Smart Retries and emails | ChurnLeak | |
|---|---|---|
| Retries failed charges | Yes, at predicted good times | No. It leaves retries to Stripe |
| Emails for failed payments | Yes, Stripe's own template | Yes, a short sequence in your product's name (days 0, 3 and 7 by default) |
| Expiring card reminders | Yes | Yes, before the next renewal |
| One total of money at risk | No | Yes, in a free audit |
| Splits "still retrying" from "needs the customer" | No | Yes, using Stripe's decline code and next retry date |
| Subscriptions with no valid card | No | Yes |
| Customers on retired prices | No | Yes |
| Shows what was recovered | Recovery analytics | Yes, per customer and in total |
| Price | Part of Stripe Billing | Free audit, then $4.99, $9.99 or $19.99 per month |
What Stripe already does well
Smart Retries is the right first step for every Stripe account. It retries at times Stripe predicts are likely to succeed, automatic card updates swap in reissued cards, and Stripe can email customers when a payment fails or a card expires. If you have not turned these on, do that first in Billing settings, Revenue recovery. Our guide to recovering failed Stripe payments walks through it.
What ChurnLeak adds
Retries cannot fix a card that is expired, blocked or replaced. Those payments need the customer, and they are easy to lose track of. ChurnLeak reads your Stripe account with a restricted read-only key, lists every unpaid failure and card problem with the amount at risk, and runs the follow-up emails for you, stopping as soon as a payment goes through.
It also catches two problems that never show up as a failed payment: active subscriptions with no card to charge, and customers still on prices you retired.
Should you use both?
Yes, for most SaaS teams. Keep Smart Retries on, and use ChurnLeak for the payments that need the customer. ChurnLeak has a free audit, then Starter at $4.99/month, Pro at $9.99/month and Growth at $19.99/month, each with a 7-day free trial, no MRR limit and no cut of what you recover. Run a free audit to see how much is still unpaid after Stripe's retries.
Common questions
Does ChurnLeak replace Stripe Smart Retries?
No. ChurnLeak leaves retries to Stripe and never charges cards itself: its key is read-only. It handles what retries cannot fix by emailing the customer to update their card.
Will customers get emails from both Stripe and ChurnLeak?
They can, if both are on. Many teams turn off Stripe's failed payment emails once ChurnLeak's recovery emails are running, and keep Smart Retries on.
See what failed payments cost you.
Connect a read-only Stripe or Paddle key and get a dollar total in two minutes. Free, no card needed.