How to recover failed Stripe payments
By the ChurnLeak team · Updated
The short answer
To recover failed Stripe payments, turn on Smart Retries and Stripe's failed payment emails, then find every payment that is still unpaid, sort it by decline reason, and email each customer a link to update their card on Stripe's hosted page. Send two or three short emails over about a week, warn customers before their card expires, and check for subscriptions with no valid card. Most failed SaaS payments are card problems, not customers who want to leave, so most of them can be won back.
Why Stripe payments fail
Most failed subscription payments are involuntary: the customer still wants the product, but the charge did not go through. Stripe records a decline code on every failed charge, and the code tells you what to do next.
| Decline code | What it means | What fixes it |
|---|---|---|
| insufficient_funds | Not enough money on the card right now | A retry a few days later often works |
| expired_card | The card on file has expired | The customer adds a new card |
| card_declined / do_not_honor | The bank refused without a reason | A retry, then the customer |
| incorrect_cvc, incorrect_number | The card details are wrong | The customer adds a new card |
| authentication_required | The bank wants 3D Secure | The customer confirms the payment |
| lost_card, stolen_card | The card was blocked | The customer adds a new card |
The split that matters: some failures fix themselves on a retry, and the rest need the customer to act. Retrying a card that is expired or reported stolen will never work, so those customers need an email right away.
Step 1: Turn on Stripe's built-in recovery
Start with the free tools Stripe already gives you. In the Stripe Dashboard, go to Billing settings, then Revenue recovery.
- Turn on Smart Retries. Stripe retries failed charges at times it predicts are most likely to succeed, over a window you choose (for example 8 retries within 2 weeks).
- Turn on the emails for failed payments and expiring cards, and point them at Stripe's hosted page where customers can update their card.
- Choose what happens when all retries fail: cancel the subscription, mark it unpaid, or leave it past due. "Mark as unpaid" keeps the subscription so a late card update can still bring it back.
- Leave automatic card updates on. Card networks pass new card numbers to Stripe when a bank reissues a card, which quietly prevents some failures.
Step 2: Find what is still unpaid
Stripe's retries and emails recover part of the money, but not all of it, and the Dashboard does not show you one total of what is still at risk. Look for four things:
- Failed payments from the last 90 days that are still unpaid, split into ones Stripe is still retrying and ones it has given up on.
- Cards that expire before the customer's next renewal.
- Active subscriptions with no valid card attached at all.
- Customers still paying a price you retired, which is quiet lost revenue rather than a failure.
You can find these with Stripe's filters and Sigma, or connect a read-only key to a tool that does it for you. ChurnLeak's free audit runs all four checks and gives one dollar total in about two minutes, and you can see a sample audit without signing up.
Step 3: Email the customers who need to act
For failures a retry cannot fix, the customer has to update their card. A short, plain email works better than a scary one. A good recovery email:
- Comes from your product name, with replies going to a real person.
- Says what happened in one sentence, without blaming the customer.
- Has one button that opens Stripe's secure page to update the card, with no login needed.
- Says what happens if nothing changes, and when.
Send a short sequence rather than one email. A common schedule is the day of the failure, three days later and a week later. ChurnLeak uses exactly that by default (days 0, 3 and 7), stops as soon as the payment goes through, and never sends more than four emails per issue.
Step 4: Prevent the next failure
The cheapest failed payment is the one that never happens.
- Email customers before their card expires, about 30 days and 7 days before renewal.
- Collect a card at signup for paid plans and trials, so no active subscription runs without one.
- Check for subscriptions with no default payment method every week.
- Watch your recovery rate over time, so a sudden rise in failures (for example after a pricing change) does not go unnoticed.
What to automate, and what tools exist
Doing all of this by hand works for a handful of customers. Past that, a failed payment recovery tool (also called dunning software) runs the checks and the emails for you. Tools differ mostly in price and in what else they do, such as cancel flows or analytics.
ChurnLeak has a free audit, then Starter at $4.99/month, Pro at $9.99/month and Growth at $19.99/month, each with a 7-day free trial, no MRR limit and no cut of what you recover. It is built for small SaaS teams on Stripe that want the checks and the recovery emails without a big retention platform. See the best failed payment recovery tools for a fair side-by-side, or compare ChurnLeak with Stripe's own retries.
Common questions
How do I recover a failed payment in Stripe?
Turn on Smart Retries and Stripe's failed payment emails in Billing settings, Revenue recovery. For payments a retry cannot fix, such as an expired or stolen card, email the customer a link to Stripe's hosted page so they can add a new card, and follow up two or three times over about a week.
How many times does Stripe retry a failed payment?
With Smart Retries on, Stripe retries according to the policy you set in Billing settings, for example up to 8 times within 2 weeks. Without Smart Retries you can set a fixed custom schedule instead.
What happens to a Stripe subscription when all retries fail?
It does what you chose in Billing settings: cancel the subscription, mark it unpaid, or leave it past due. Marking it unpaid keeps the subscription, so the customer can still pay later by updating their card.
What is dunning?
Dunning is the process of contacting customers about failed or overdue payments so they update their payment details. For SaaS it usually means automatic payment retries plus a short sequence of recovery emails.
What is a good failed payment recovery rate?
It varies a lot by audience and price point, so the best benchmark is your own number before and after you add retries and emails. Track it monthly: recovered amount divided by the total that failed.
See what failed payments cost you.
Connect a read-only Stripe or Paddle key and get a dollar total in two minutes. Free, no card needed.